Greetings, and thank you very much for your continued support of Journal of East China Jiaotong University!
In view of your academic expertise and standing in the field, we sincerely appreciate your willingness to review manuscripts for our journal despite your busy schedule. When evaluating a manuscript, we kindly ask you to assess its scientific value objectively and fairly, with attention to the following aspects:
Please provide a comprehensive evaluation of the manuscript’s research topic, originality, academic level, and theoretical or practical significance.
Does the manuscript involve any confidential information, or contain any instances of plagiarism, copyright infringement, or violations of scientific ethics?
Are the research methods appropriate? Is the logical reasoning sound? Are the data and results reliable? Are the conclusions valid, or are there any overstatements or inaccuracies?
Is the title concise and clear? Does the abstract accurately, concisely, and completely reflect the main content of the paper? Does the abstract include all four key components: research objective, main methods, results, and conclusions? Are the selected keywords appropriate?
Is the introduction concise and reflective of the current research status in the field? Is the research content of the paper clearly presented?
Are the references properly cited? Are any key references in the field missing?
Are the language expressions in both Chinese and English appropriate? Are the mathematical formulas, figures, and tables used correctly? Are there any redundant or repetitive sections?
For any parts requiring revision, please provide specific suggestions; for sections that should be condensed, please indicate explicitly (e.g., compress by 1/5 or 1/4).
To help minimize delays and promptly publish authors’ latest research findings, we kindly ask you to return your review comments within the specified timeframe. If you are unfamiliar with the manuscript’s content or are currently too busy to complete the review in time, please recommend another suitable expert or notify the editorial office as soon as possible to avoid delays.
To facilitate communication between reviewers and the editorial office, we have created a WeChat group for our reviewers. If you would like to join, please add our editor Li Gen on WeChat (WeChat ID: lidagn), and he will invite you to join the group (as the group already has over 200 members, joining is by invitation only).
