Thank you very much for your support to Journal of East China Jiaotong University.
Considering your academic standing in this field, the journal would like to invite you to review the manuscript. Please objectively and fairly evaluate the paper on its scientific value. The instructions are as followed.
1. Please provide a comprehensive evaluation on the paper’s topic, creativity, academic level, and theoretical and practical value of the manuscript.
2. Does the manuscript involve confidential breach? Is there any violation of copyright law or misconduct such as plagiarism?
3. Is the methodology reasonable? Is logical reasoning appropriate? Are the data and results reliable? Is the conclusion appropriate? Are there any exaggerations or inaccuracies?
4. Is the title concise and to-the-point? Does the abstract accurately, concisely, and completely reflect the main content of the paper? Does the abstract include four elements (objective, methods, results, and conclusions)? Are the keywords appropriate?
5. Does the introduction concisely reflects the current research status in the field? Is the research content of the paper clearly summarized?
6. Are the references appropriate? Do authors neglect any important references in this field?
7. Is the use of Chinese and English language expressions, mathematical formulas, diagrams, and tables appropriate? Is there any redundant content?
8. Please indicate the paragraphs that need revising. The parts suggested to be compressed should also be specified with a ratio, such as 1/5 or 1/4.
In order to shorten the processing time and publish the latest research results, please try your best to return your review comments within the specified time. If you are not familiar with the content of the manuscript or could not complete the review within the specified time, please recommend other experts or inform the editorial office as soon as possible to avoid delay in the review.